Action Society is outraged after the sentencing of Sivuyile Tshabile, convicted of the brutal murder of Nosiphiwo James, was once again postponed at the Khayelitsha Regional Court today. The matter has now been rescheduled to 12 November 2025.
This latest delay comes after months of postponements since Tshabile was found guilty in May 2025. The court heard that the probation report required for sentencing is still not before the court. The prosecutor had met with the probation officer twice. She also confirmed that she had forwarded the defence’s contact details to the probation officer and informed the court that the accused did not co-operate with the probation officer.
In court today, the magistrate questioned Tshabile about his failure to engage with the probation officer. His responses were vague, claiming he “didn’t know” and that he would not speak to the officer without his lawyer present. When pressed, Tshabile finally said he would co-operate. The magistrate warned him that this is his final opportunity to do so and made it clear that the court will proceed with sentencing at the next appearance regardless.
Nosiphiwo was murdered with a screwdriver in May 2022. After the killing, Tshabile fled to the Eastern Cape and evaded arrest until Action Society assisted SAPS in tracking him down. Since then, her family has faced repeated postponements due to missing documents, absent witnesses, and administrative failures. Even after conviction, the process has continued to drag, forcing Nosiphiwo’s loved ones to wait endlessly for closure.
“Today was supposed to bring justice for Nosiphiwo’s family, but instead it brought more pain,” said Kaylynn Palm, head of Action Society’s Action Centre in the Western Cape. “We commend the state for doing their part in this case, but it is clear that Tshabile himself is to blame for these delays. His refusal to co-operate with the probation officer shows complete disregard for the justice process and for Nosiphiwo’s family. Enough is enough – this must be the very last delay.”
Action Society demands that the court honour its warning and proceed on 12 November without further excuses. South Africa’s justice system cannot continue protecting perpetrators with endless procedural loopholes while grieving families are left in limbo.
Soundbite:
